Making Friends at a Hostel When You Are Not a Natural Extrovert

I booked six nights at Red Star and spent the first one hiding. Not dramatically—I did not cry in a bathroom or anything—I just climbed onto my top bunk at eight in the evening, pulled the curtain across, and read the same page of a paperback four times while the common room laughed downstairs. If that sounds familiar, this is for you. It is the story of how a genuinely quiet person learned to make friends in a hostel, told by one, with the practical bits pulled out at the end.

The first night, and the story I told myself

I am not shy in the clinical sense. I can do a job interview. I can ask directions. What I cannot do, or could not, is walk into a room of people who already seem to know each other and insert myself into it. Hostels, from the outside, look like that room all the time. Everyone appears to have arrived in a group and formed a band.

So on that first night I told myself the usual story: they are all extroverts, they all travel in packs, this place is not for people like me. I would use the hostel as a bed and do the coast on my own. Which was fine, honestly. The coast is beautiful and I am good company for myself. But I had come partly to meet people, and by the second morning I was already a bit lonely.

The kitchen at the wrong time

What changed things was not courage. It was timing. I went down to make coffee at half past seven because I could not sleep, and the kitchen was empty apart from one person from the night before, a Dutch woman about my age, quietly eating toast and looking as tired as I felt. Nobody else. No band. Just two people and a kettle.

We did not talk much. She asked if I wanted the last of the milk. I asked if the bread was communal. That was more or less it. But when the room filled up an hour later and got loud, I had one face I recognised, and when she said she was walking out to the old fort and did I want to come, saying yes was the easiest thing in the world.

That was my first real lesson: the hostel is not one room, it is a dozen rooms at different times of day, and the quiet ones are where quiet people meet.

Walks are better than bars

The walk to the fort is about an hour along the cliff path, and it turns out an hour of walking side by side is the ideal format for someone like me. There is no eye contact to maintain. There are natural pauses. When the conversation runs dry you can point at a bird. By the time we reached the walls we had covered where we were from, why we were travelling and what we were both slightly running away from, without any of it feeling like an interview.

Over the next few days I noticed this pattern everywhere. The bar in the evening was the hardest place to make a friend and the easiest place to feel excluded. The day trips, the kitchen, the laundry room, the bench outside where people waited for the bus—those were where the actual connections happened. They were also where I met the other quiet ones, who had been there all along, doing exactly what I had been doing.

One person, then two, then a table

I never did learn to walk into a room. What I learned instead was to build the room around me, slowly. On the third night the Dutch woman and I cooked pasta together, and a Canadian guy asked if there was enough for three. There was. On the fourth night the three of us went to the pub quiz the hostel runs, which I would never have attended alone, and we came a proud second-to-last. By the fifth night there were six of us at the big table and I was the one who had booked it.

From the outside, that table would have looked exactly like the intimidating group I had hidden from on night one. That was the strangest realisation of the week. The groups are not closed. They are just further along a process that always starts with two people and a kettle.

What the staff do that you do not notice

I only understood afterwards how much of this the hostel had quietly arranged. The kitchen has one big table rather than several small ones. The notice board has a sheet where you can write your name against a day trip. The quiz needs teams of four to six, so odd numbers get merged. The woman on reception, when I checked in, had mentioned the fort walk and the quiz in a way that sounded casual and was not. None of it forces anyone to talk. All of it makes talking easier. If you are choosing a hostel and you are nervous about meeting people, look for signs of that kind of design.

What I would tell my first-night self

  • Go to the shared spaces at the quiet hours. Early breakfast, mid-afternoon, late laundry. That is where the other introverts are.
  • Say yes to anything with walking in it. Side-by-side is easier than face-to-face, and the coast does half the talking.
  • Have a task. Cooking, washing up, making tea. It gives your hands something to do and gives people a reason to approach you.
  • Aim for one person, not the room. One real conversation a day is plenty. The group builds itself.
  • Use the hostel’s structure. Sign-up sheets, quizzes, group dinners. You do not have to be the one who starts something.
  • Give yourself permission to retreat. The curtain on the bunk is not a failure. It is how you recharge for tomorrow.
  • Remember everyone leaves. The person who seems unapproachable tonight is checking out on Thursday. So is the awkwardness.

Six nights later

I left on the seventh morning with three numbers in my phone, a standing invitation to a flat in Utrecht and a photograph of five people I had known for less than a week, squinting into the wind on top of a fort. I am still not an extrovert. I still hide on the first night, most places. But I know now that the first night is not the hostel. The hostel is what happens after you come down for coffee.